2 registered members (Sandhurst, carmine),
126
guests, and 3
spiders. |
Key:
Admin,
Global Mod,
Mod
|
|
Forums69
Topics113,660
Posts1,341,532
Members1,821
|
Most Online731 Jan 14th, 2020
|
|
|
Balance Shafts
#879786
10/08/2009 19:23
10/08/2009 19:23
|
tom_snelling
Unregistered
|
tom_snelling
Unregistered
|
Right, whats the general concesus about removing these?
Remove the belt & tensioner only, leaving the shafts in place?
or....
Remove the belt & tensioner, shafts and blank the ends?
PROS AND CONS FOR EACH PLEASE!
|
|
|
Re: Balance Shafts
[Re: ]
#879813
10/08/2009 20:18
10/08/2009 20:18
|
1NRO
Unregistered
|
1NRO
Unregistered
|
I'd remove them completly but thats an engine out job. Means you can block the centre bearing which might is you've got a less than perfect oil pressure help restore it. Removing them completly gets rid of a big weight too.
Nik
|
|
|
Re: Balance Shafts
[Re: stevo]
#879836
10/08/2009 20:42
10/08/2009 20:42
|
tom_snelling
Unregistered
|
tom_snelling
Unregistered
|
The engine is out on an engine crane at the moment.
|
|
|
Re: Balance Shafts
[Re: ]
#879854
10/08/2009 21:12
10/08/2009 21:12
|
Martijn
Unregistered
|
Martijn
Unregistered
|
Then you can remove, mine are blocked atm.
|
|
|
Re: Balance Shafts
[Re: ]
#879879
10/08/2009 21:53
10/08/2009 21:53
|
tom_snelling
Unregistered
|
tom_snelling
Unregistered
|
Has anyone removed and locked theirs off?
|
|
|
Re: Balance Shafts
[Re: ]
#880018
11/08/2009 09:15
11/08/2009 09:15
|
Joined: Dec 2005
Posts: 12,295 Sandhurst
Begbie
Ex El Presidente
|
Ex El Presidente
I AM a Coop
Joined: Dec 2005
Posts: 12,295
Sandhurst
|
You won't be saving that much weight by removing them. All depends on how much weight you want to loose from it, as you will probably loose about 4KG from removing the shafts, otherwise, just leave them in place, lock them up and forgot about it
Your car is Usain Bolt with wellies
|
|
|
Re: Balance Shafts
[Re: Begbie]
#880401
11/08/2009 18:10
11/08/2009 18:10
|
tom_snelling
Unregistered
|
tom_snelling
Unregistered
|
How would I go about locking them?
|
|
|
Re: Balance Shafts
[Re: ]
#880408
11/08/2009 18:25
11/08/2009 18:25
|
shinyshoes
Unregistered
|
shinyshoes
Unregistered
|
i have to ask... why would you remove these anyway?
our 16v is in for cam belt and service as we speak, now i bought a complete belt kit, cam belt, balance belt
etc and all bearings/tensioners etc.
the guy phoned me today and told me that the balance belt was completly shagged and only had around 100 miles left!
excuse my ignorance but why would you remove a part like this from the engine?
surely there is only one long term outcome???
Last edited by shinyshoes; 11/08/2009 18:26.
|
|
|
Re: Balance Shafts
[Re: ]
#880412
11/08/2009 18:31
11/08/2009 18:31
|
eldinho
Unregistered
|
eldinho
Unregistered
|
they take power from the engine. If you have balanced internals they can be removed, like I have done.
|
|
|
Re: Balance Shafts
[Re: ]
#880418
11/08/2009 18:38
11/08/2009 18:38
|
shinyshoes
Unregistered
|
shinyshoes
Unregistered
|
ok, so why are they there in the first place?
|
|
|
Re: Balance Shafts
[Re: Jimbo]
#880516
11/08/2009 20:50
11/08/2009 20:50
|
tom_snelling
Unregistered
|
tom_snelling
Unregistered
|
As far as I know, they just arent required on a 16VT, which is obviously only a 4 pot.
I know a couple of people who have removed them that are going for reasonably high power on their 16VTs.
|
|
|
Re: Balance Shafts
[Re: Jimbo]
#880544
11/08/2009 21:21
11/08/2009 21:21
|
1NRO
Unregistered
|
1NRO
Unregistered
|
In the 16v's case after years of rotating at twice crank speed with the purpose of absobing a tiny imbalance (which really it small) they like to wear the centre bearing which is fed oil from the crank centre main, one of the bigger culprits for loss of oil pressure that's shortly followed by engine failure. The complex and fragile nature of the belts and outer bearings (which seize on older engines as they never get replaced, the ones in the block) and the fact it's all very close to the cambelt make for potential belt failure when it gives up the ghost and pulls the cam belt off with it. The increase in turning torque the engine has with this system means a benifit in horsepower when they are done away with which if they are removed completly and the centre bearing dealt with will also allow a better supply of oil to the centre main and rod bearings. Not too sure how the 20v system is catered for but I'd imagine there'd be similar benefits to doing without them.
Nik
|
|
|
Re: Balance Shafts
[Re: ]
#880659
11/08/2009 23:08
11/08/2009 23:08
|
GT_SEB0
Unregistered
|
GT_SEB0
Unregistered
|
i have my engine in the car obviously can i just cut the balance belt and remove it and hey presto done?
would this work
|
|
|
Re: Balance Shafts
[Re: ]
#880698
12/08/2009 01:17
12/08/2009 01:17
|
Joined: Dec 2006
Posts: 759 England
Danhgt
Enjoying the ride
|
Enjoying the ride
Joined: Dec 2006
Posts: 759
England
|
i have my engine in the car obviously can i just cut the balance belt and remove it and hey presto done?
would this work Thats all I done, I had the engine out and just fitted new shell bearings in the middle with a big washer behind the pulleys to stop them rotating. I don't see how you could block the central oil feed for the front shaft, theres no access?
|
|
|
Re: Balance Shafts
[Re: Danhgt]
#880700
12/08/2009 01:25
12/08/2009 01:25
|
GT_SEB0
Unregistered
|
GT_SEB0
Unregistered
|
would it matter if i didnt lock the pulleys as i dont fancy remopving my timing belt
|
|
|
Re: Balance Shafts
[Re: ]
#881753
12/08/2009 07:55
12/08/2009 07:55
|
1NRO
Unregistered
|
1NRO
Unregistered
|
If you cut the belt and leave at that the cambelt runs against the idler and rotates the balance shaft.
I've a bung which has a threaded hole in it which using a LONG bolt or a length of threaded rod can be guided into the block to locate in position before either pressing it in or persuaded home with a suitable wooden drift and tapping stick :-)easy job and peace of mind. No loose oil clearances once thats in position.
|
|
|
Re: Balance Shafts
[Re: ]
#887761
23/08/2009 21:00
23/08/2009 21:00
|
GT_SEB0
Unregistered
|
GT_SEB0
Unregistered
|
just to bring this thread back im gunna cut my balance belt off tomorrow with a little guidence from here.
how do you lock the blance shafts off as i cant remove mine
pics maybe good
Last edited by GT_SEB0; 23/08/2009 21:06.
|
|
|
Re: Balance Shafts
[Re: ]
#888355
24/08/2009 23:30
24/08/2009 23:30
|
MattW
Unregistered
|
MattW
Unregistered
|
I would remove them if I had the opportunity purely because they are a compromise...
|
|
|
Re: Balance Shafts
[Re: ]
#888831
25/08/2009 21:32
25/08/2009 21:32
|
J_K
Unregistered
|
J_K
Unregistered
|
|
|
|
Re: Balance Shafts
[Re: ]
#888909
25/08/2009 23:43
25/08/2009 23:43
|
Akeme
Unregistered
|
Akeme
Unregistered
|
The 20vt engine does not have a balance belt.
Alfa 4 pots do, and the 16v.
|
|
|
Re: Balance Shafts
[Re: ]
#888924
26/08/2009 01:14
26/08/2009 01:14
|
GT_SEB0
Unregistered
|
GT_SEB0
Unregistered
|
i dont really have the accesss you do as you have your head off, Is it only the rear balance shaft that needs to be clamped and can te belt be removed without me ripping half of the engine off just to get to it?
|
|
|
Re: Balance Shafts
[Re: ]
#888977
26/08/2009 09:57
26/08/2009 09:57
|
J_K
Unregistered
|
J_K
Unregistered
|
I never really thought about it with the head on. You probably wouldn't easily be able to get to them with the head, engine stabiliser, metal cover on!
I'm not certain but I think if you just take the top 3 bolts out of the timing belt cover and move the coolant bottle out of the way you should be able to cut the belt and get it off. Best wait for somebody else to confirm that though!
I'm not certain they actually need to be locked, I know a few alfa owners that remove the belt and just leave the shafts as they are and haven't had any problems. I just did it because it was easy when I'd the head off.
|
|
|
|